Biotech Patents
Equivalency and Exclusion Under European and Us Patent Law
By: Li Westerlund
Hardcover | 29 August 2002
At a Glance
364 Pages
23.39 x 15.6 x 2.06
Hardcover
$366.00
or 4 interest-free payments of $91.50 with
orAims to ship in 7 to 10 business days
The material for the analyses includes the European practices under the EPC, those of the United Kingdom, Germany, and the US. The mandated exclusions from patentability under the European patent laws of categories of plant and animal subject matter and certain biological processes are also analysed.
Claim interpretation is the common theme. The challenge has been to present a comprehensive basis for grasping the substantive law for the field of biotechnology. The book examines thoroughly the differences between practices, and the consequences of those differences for the possibility of being granted a patent for an invention, and the infringement doctrines' effects for what might be called a patent's 'after-life', i.e. the scope of its protection.
The principal message emerging in this book is the importance of relying on the policy arguments of uniformity and predictability in order to preserve a fair balance between an inventor and third parties, since in reality much of the controversy in this field turns on proper protection.
Introduction | p. 1 |
Patents to Life Forms | p. 1 |
International and Regional Legal Instruments | p. 4 |
Eligibility | p. 5 |
The Basic Patentability Criteria | p. 6 |
Genetic Engineering | p. 7 |
Incentive to Invent | p. 9 |
Economics | p. 10 |
Intangible Content | p. 11 |
Drawbacks | p. 12 |
Complex Legal Situation | p. 13 |
Invention | p. 15 |
Exclusions from Patentability | p. 16 |
Proper Balance | p. 16 |
The Complex Picture Behind the Patent Systems | p. 17 |
Classical Methods of Assessing Patent Law | p. 18 |
Changes in Patent Practice Affect the Protection | p. 19 |
Trade Secret and Copyright Protection | p. 20 |
Scope of Study | p. 21 |
Division | p. 21 |
Mode of Operation | p. 22 |
Invention or Discovery | p. 23 |
Invention | p. 24 |
Legal Definition | p. 25 |
Invention as Opposed to Discovery | p. 25 |
Broadened Concept | p. 26 |
Typology | p. 26 |
Natural-Technological Processes | p. 27 |
Living Organisms- Products of Nature | p. 27 |
No New Properties | p. 28 |
Creation By Man | p. 28 |
Technical Means- New Organisms | p. 29 |
Living Organisms and Their Parts Patentable | p. 30 |
Prepared in Non-Natural Forms | p. 32 |
CDNA's are not 'Natural Products' | p. 33 |
Remarks | p. 34 |
Analysis | p. 35 |
Challenge of Traditional Concepts | p. 35 |
A Technical Solution (I) | p. 36 |
The Utilisaton of Natural Forces (II) | p. 38 |
The Inventive Kernel | p. 40 |
Existing in Nature | p. 42 |
The Human Body and Parts of the Human Body | p. 45 |
Not Freely Occurring in Nature | p. 47 |
Modifications at the Molecular Level | p. 48 |
The Necessity of Human Intervention | p. 49 |
The Result of Human Intelligence | p. 50 |
Patentability Problems | p. 52 |
Patentable Subject Matter | p. 53 |
An Exclusive Right to Exploit | p. 53 |
Production or Business Purpose | p. 56 |
Concluding Remarks | p. 56 |
Disclosure | p. 59 |
Functions of Disclosure | p. 60 |
Disclosing Inventions | p. 62 |
Identity of Invention | p. 63 |
The EPC | p. 63 |
Art. 83 EPC-Art. 84 EPC | p. 64 |
Disclosure and Scope of Claims | p. 65 |
Indentity of Invention | p. 68 |
Complex Technology | p. 68 |
Disclosed Indentity | p. 71 |
Identity Determination | p. 72 |
One Way to Carry out the Invention | p. 73 |
Proper Balance | p. 75 |
Rule of Presumption | p. 75 |
Not a Fixed Rule | p. 77 |
Serious Doubts | p. 77 |
Reversal of Proof | p. 78 |
Undue Burden of Experimentation | p. 79 |
Identical Results | p. 80 |
Repeatability of Examples | p. 81 |
Breadth of Claims | p. 82 |
Reproductability | p. 84 |
Sufficiently Disclosed | p. 86 |
The British Approach | p. 87 |
Practical Use | p. 89 |
Quid Pro Quo | p. 91 |
Concluding Remarks | p. 92 |
U.S. Patent Law | p. 92 |
Utility | p. 93 |
The EST Issue | p. 96 |
Partial Remedy for Overly Broad Claims | p. 97 |
Change in View | p. 98 |
Factual Proof | p. 99 |
The Biotechnological Field | p. 101 |
The USPTO Guideline | p. 102 |
Enablement | p. 105 |
Undue Burden of Experimentation | p. 106 |
Step-by-Step Method | p. 108 |
Effect Achieved Later On | p. 110 |
Technological Complexity | p. 112 |
Potential Rejection | p. 114 |
Broad Claims | p. 115 |
Factual Proof of Enablement | p. 117 |
Complex Biological Phenomena | p. 118 |
Remarks | p. 122 |
Strict Interpretation | p. 124 |
Concluding Remarks on Disclosure | p. 126 |
Early Filing | p. 127 |
Required Use | p. 129 |
Claim Drafting | p. 130 |
Comparative Aspects | p. 131 |
Scope of Claims | p. 132 |
Scope of Protection the Main Issue | p. 135 |
Protection | p. 137 |
Literal Infringement-British Law | p. 139 |
German Law | p. 141 |
The U.S. Practice | p. 142 |
Literal Protection | p. 145 |
Claim Limitations | p. 147 |
Literal Protection | p. 148 |
Remarks | p. 150 |
Equivalency | p. 151 |
British Practice | p. 152 |
Purposive Construction | p. 154 |
Claim Construction | p. 156 |
Threshold Test | p. 157 |
Material Effect | p. 159 |
After-Developed Technology | p. 159 |
The EPC-Requirements | p. 161 |
Claim Limitations | p. 163 |
Harmonisation | p. 165 |
The 'New' Approach | p. 167 |
Application of Equivalents | p. 170 |
German Practice | p. 171 |
Doctrine of Equivalents | p. 172 |
Indirect Equivalency | p. 174 |
Obviousness | p. 175 |
Chemical and Biochemical Patents | p. 176 |
Disclosure as Basis | p. 178 |
Claim Limitations | p. 179 |
Harmonisation | p. 182 |
The New Practice | p. 184 |
European Harmonisation | p. 187 |
Different Outcomes | p. 188 |
The EC Directive | p. 188 |
Translucent Approach | p. 190 |
Remarks | p. 192 |
U.S. Practice | p. 193 |
Equivalent Changes | p. 194 |
Biochemical Inventions | p. 196 |
Biotechnological Inventions | p. 199 |
Case Law | p. 202 |
Claim Litigation | p. 205 |
Standard of Difference | p. 206 |
Element-by-Element | p. 207 |
The FWR Test and Standard of Differences | p. 211 |
Functional Claim Language | p. 213 |
De Novo Claim Construction | p. 215 |
Restrictions of the Doctrine | p. 217 |
Freely Usable State of the Art | p. 219 |
Remarks | p. 221 |
Basis | p. 222 |
Summarising Remarks | p. 223 |
Different Policies | p. 225 |
Different Practicies | p. 228 |
Uncertainty | p. 229 |
Decisive Aspects for Infringement | p. 231 |
Element-By-Element Contra Invention-As-A-Whole | p. 232 |
Point in Time | p. 234 |
Comparative Conclusions | p. 236 |
Exclusions from Patentability | p. 239 |
The Purpose | p. 240 |
International Regulations | p. 240 |
Europe | p. 242 |
The Concept of 'Plant Variety' | p. 245 |
The Regulation | p. 246 |
The Criteria | p. 248 |
Remarks | p. 250 |
EPC Case Law | p. 251 |
The Interpretation | p. 254 |
Questions Answered | p. 255 |
Points of Interpretation Cleared | p. 257 |
Proper Interpretation | p. 258 |
A Substantive Approach | p. 262 |
Remarks | p. 263 |
Analysis | p. 264 |
Protectable Varieties | p. 266 |
Technical Feasibility | p. 267 |
Patent and Plant Breeder's Right Protection | p. 268 |
Protectable Plant Variety | p. 270 |
Accept the PBR Definition | p. 270 |
Relevant Criteria | p. 272 |
Clarification by the EC Directive | p. 274 |
Scope of Protection | p. 276 |
Well-Balanced System | p. 277 |
Weighting Pros and Cons | p. 278 |
The Concept of Animal Variety | p. 280 |
Legal Problems Specific to Animals | p. 283 |
Unclear Concept | p. 284 |
Proper Interpretation | p. 286 |
Methods of Interpretation | p. 287 |
Clarification | p. 288 |
The Purpose of Law | p. 290 |
Analogous Application of the DUS Criteria | p. 291 |
Concluding Remarks | p. 292 |
Other Ways to Protect Varieties (Excurs) US Law | p. 294 |
U.S. Plant Protection | p. 294 |
Patent Protection vs. Copyright Protection | p. 297 |
A Sui Generis System | p. 299 |
Process Plants | p. 303 |
Technical Character | p. 304 |
A Higher Level of Technicality | p. 305 |
Interpretation | p. 306 |
Analysis | p. 308 |
Technical Standard | p. 309 |
Effect of End Product | p. 310 |
Microbiological Processes and Their Products | p. 311 |
EPC Case Law | p. 311 |
Method of Interpretation | p. 313 |
The Concept | p. 314 |
Objective Technological Method | p. 316 |
Analysing Remarks | p. 317 |
Application | p. 318 |
Overall Analysis | p. 321 |
Analytical Framework | p. 322 |
Defined Right | p. 322 |
No Satisfactory Solution | p. 323 |
Plant Variety | p. 324 |
Standpoint of PBR Law | p. 325 |
Alternative Legal Understanding | p. 326 |
The Animal Variety Concept | p. 328 |
Shift in Perspective | p. 329 |
Alternate Understanding | p. 329 |
Essentially Biological Process | p. 331 |
Comprehensive View | p. 332 |
Microbiological Process | p. 332 |
Intrinsic Incoherence | p. 333 |
Historical Explanation | p. 334 |
Point of Departure | p. 336 |
Available Protection | p. 337 |
Double Protection | p. 338 |
Cross- and Compulsory Licensing (Excurs) | p. 339 |
Other Kinds of Protection (Excurs) | p. 341 |
Remarks | p. 341 |
Predictable Basis | p. 343 |
Rules of Interpretation | p. 344 |
Different Solutions | p. 345 |
Distinguishable Aspects | p. 346 |
Range of Equivalents | p. 348 |
Proper Basis | p. 349 |
Table of Contents provided by Syndetics. All Rights Reserved. |
ISBN: 9789041188830
ISBN-10: 9041188835
Published: 29th August 2002
Format: Hardcover
Language: English
Number of Pages: 364
Audience: Professional and Scholarly
Publisher: Kluwer Law International, BV
Country of Publication: NL
Dimensions (cm): 23.39 x 15.6 x 2.06
Weight (kg): 0.9
Shipping
Standard Shipping | Express Shipping | |
---|---|---|
Metro postcodes: | $9.99 | $14.95 |
Regional postcodes: | $9.99 | $14.95 |
Rural postcodes: | $9.99 | $14.95 |
How to return your order
At Booktopia, we offer hassle-free returns in accordance with our returns policy. If you wish to return an item, please get in touch with Booktopia Customer Care.
Additional postage charges may be applicable.
Defective items
If there is a problem with any of the items received for your order then the Booktopia Customer Care team is ready to assist you.
For more info please visit our Help Centre.
You Can Find This Book In
A Lawyer's Guide to Section 337 Investigations Before the U.S. International Trade Commission, Fifth Edition
Paperback
RRP $270.00
$167.25
OFF