No Magic Wand : The Idealization of Science in Law - David S. Caudill

No Magic Wand

The Idealization of Science in Law

By: David S. Caudill, Lewis H. LaRue

Hardcover | 29 June 2006

At a Glance

Hardcover


$372.50

or 4 interest-free payments of $93.13 with

 or 

Aims to ship in 10 to 15 business days

When will this arrive by?
Enter delivery postcode to estimate

Since 1993, Supreme Court precedent has asked judges to serve as gatekeepers to their expert witnesses, admitting only reliable scientific testimony. Lacking a strong background in science, however, some judges admit dubious scientific testimony packages by articulate practitioners, while others reject reliable evidence that is unreasonably portrayed as full of holes. Seeking a balance between undue deference and undeserved skepticism, Caudill and LaRue draw on the philosophy of science to help judges, juries, and advocates better understand its goals and limitations. Published in cooperation with The Center for Public Justice.
Industry Reviews
Legal actors' understanding of how scientific knowledge is produced is a matter of immense and increasing importance in contemporary society. Caudill and LaRue make a significant contribution to this debate by drawing on science studies research as a prophylactic against the temptation to adopt idealized or "romantic," as they call them, images of scientific activity. No Magic Wand demonstrates that bringing a science studies perspective to bear on legal problems leads, not to meaningless relativism, but to a profoundly pragmatic approach to assessing the value of knowledge claims that invoke the mantle of science. -- Simon A. Cole, author of Suspect Identities: A History of Fingerprinting and Criminal Identification
No Magic Wand is a tour-de-force that bridges the gap between jurisprudence and science studies. Caudill and LaRue successfully illustrate how law idealizes science and the problems this causes for the courts as well as for science. In this "brave new world" after the Supreme Court's decision in Daubert, their solution-that courts view science as a pragmatic activity-will resonate both with scientists and lawyers. Every judge and lawyer grappling with scientific evidence, and every scientist testifying in court, should read this book. -- Richard E. Redding, Villanova University School of Law
Caudill and LaRue have written an erudite, deeply considered, and highly readable account of the tension between the two cultures of law and science, the tendency of lawyers and judges to oscillate between credulity and dismissiveness when confronted by scientific testimony, and the need in short for legal professionals to acquire a more accurate understanding of the strengths and limitations of science in the legal process. -- Richard A. Posner, U.S. Circuit Judge
On the whole, No Magic Wand is readable and interesting. It is useful in that it provides specific examples from cases to show how various judges have interpreted the Daubert criteria. The book will be more useful to those less familiar with the problems associated with using scientific evidence in the courtroom. * Journal of Law & Politics *
In No Magic Wand, Caudill and LaRue impart valuable wisdom for the beginner as well as the advanced legal scholar. Coverage ranges from the basics - the current tests for scientific and technical evidence - to the most sophisticated questions raised by commentators on forensic jurisprudence. The debate over how much courts should defer to experts is a key issue in the "science wars," and the treatment of it in Chapter Three is trenchant and profound. This book is a must read for lawyers, professors, or judges who are seeking to come to grips with the scientific processes in the courtroom. -- Ronald L. Carlson, Fuller E. Callaway Professor of Law, The University of Georgia

Other Editions and Formats

Paperback

Published: 29th June 2006

More in Jurisprudence & General Issues

Parker and Evans's Inside Lawyers' Ethics : 4th Edition - Francesca  Bartlett
Principles of Administrative Law : 4th Edition - Leighton McDonald

RRP $151.95

$124.90

18%
OFF
Crime, Criminality and Criminal Justice : 3rd edition - Rob White
Practical Legal Skills : 5th edition - Ross Hyams

RRP $75.95

$66.75

12%
OFF
Civil Dispute Resolution : Balancing Themes and Theory - Sonya  Willis
Researching and Writing in Law : 4th Edition - Terry Hutchinson

RRP $150.00

$129.50

14%
OFF
Media Law : Cases, Material and Commentary 3rd Edition - David Rolph
Connecting With Law : 5th Edition - Michelle Sanson

RRP $124.95

$104.50

16%
OFF
The New Lawyer : 3rd Edition - Nickolas James

RRP $131.95

$115.35

13%
OFF
Legal Studies for VCE Units 1 & 2 Student Book+obook pro : 15th Edition - Lisa Filippin
Statutory Interpretation : 2nd edition - Michelle Sanson

RRP $99.95

$85.90

14%
OFF
Connecting with Law 5e and Statutory Interpretation 2e Value Pack - Michelle Sanson
Examining Crime and Justice around the World : Global Viewpoints - Janet P. Stamatel
Horizontal Rights : An Institutional Approach - Gautam Bhatia

RRP $84.99

$67.50

21%
OFF
True Tracks : Respecting Indigenous knowledge and culture - Terri Janke