How do journalists know what they know? Who gets to decide what good journalism is and when it's done right? What sort of expertise do journalists have, and what role should and do they play in society? Until a couple of decades ago, journalists rarely asked these questions, largely because the answers were generally undisputed. Now, the stakes are rising for journalists as they face real-time critique and audience pushback for their ethics, news reporting, and relevance. Yet the crises facing journalism have been narrowly defined as the result of disruption by new technologies and economic decline. This book argues that the concerns are in fact much more profound.
Drawing on their five years of research with journalists in the U.S. and Canada, in a variety of news organizations from startups and freelancers to mainstream media, the authors find a digital reckoning taking place regarding journalism's founding ideals and methods. The book explores journalism's long-standing representational harms, arguing that despite thoughtful explorations of the role of publics in journalism, the profession hasn't adequately addressed matters of gender, race, intersectionality, and settler colonialism. In doing so, the authors rethink the basis for what journalism says it could and should do, suggesting that a turn to strong objectivity and systems journalism provides a path forward. They offer insights from journalists' own experiences and efforts at repair, reform, and transformation to consider how journalism can address its limits and possibilities along with widening media publics.
Industry Reviews
"Callison and Young mount a fullfrontal assault on the 'view from nowhere' and challenge us to understand that whose stories get told and who is able to tell them are critical factors in ensuring that journalism remains an essential pillar of democratic societies" -- Ethan Zuckerman, Center for Civic Media, MIT
"This rich, important book brings the lessons of feminist anthropology, science studies, and history itself to bear on contemporary journalism. Norms of objectivity and traditional business models may be crumbling, but as this book shows, a new and better world of grounded, reflexive reporting is waiting to be won" -- Fred Turner, Stanford University
"Veteran journalists Candis Callison and Mary Lynn Young use unflinching eyes to capture the true picture of journalism in Canada, looking in every newsroom corner, to see if the profession can survive the current assault against it, and, if it deserves to. Every aspiring journalist, communicator or media professional should read this book in order to get an insider's glimpse into how news is made, who makes the decisions shaping what we see, hear and read
daily, and, where the gaping holes are" -- Tanya Talaga,
"The world is on fire and the public doesn't simply need better reporting on the height of the blaze, the strength of the wind, and the extent of the damage, however important. We also urgently need to put out the blaze! Reckoning offers a powerful call to action, coupling ethnographic insights and visionary analyses, situating journalism within a wider field of action, and offering deeply incisive accounts of what it means to be a systems journalist-one who
cares not only about what happened, but what will happen."-Ruha Benjamin, Princeton University
"Veteran journalists Candis Callison and Mary Lynn Young use unflinching eyes to capture the true picture of journalism in Canada, looking in every newsroom corner, to see if the profession can survive the current assault against it, and, if it deserves to. Every aspiring journalist, communicator or media professional should read this book in order to get `n insider's glimpse into how news is made, who makes the decisions shaping what we see, hear and read
daily, and, where the gaping holes are."-Tanya Talaga
"This rich, important book brings the lessons of feminist anthropology, science studies, and history itself to bear on contemporary journalism. Norms of objectivity and traditional business models may be crumbling, but as this book shows, a new and better world of grounded, reflexive reporting is waiting to be won."-Fred Turner, Stanford University
"Callison and Young mount a full-frontal assault on the 'view from nowhere' and challenge us to understand that whose stories get told and who is able to tell them are critical factors in ensuring that journalism remains an essential pillar of democratic societies."-Ethan Zuckerman, Center for Civic Media, MIT
