The Logic of Precedent : Constraint, Freedom, and Common Law Reasoning - John Horty

The Logic of Precedent

Constraint, Freedom, and Common Law Reasoning

By: John Horty

Hardcover | 27 February 2025

At a Glance

Hardcover


RRP $173.95

$168.75

or 4 interest-free payments of $42.19 with

 or 

Aims to ship in 7 to 10 business days

When will this arrive by?
Enter delivery postcode to estimate

Unlike statutory law, which relies on the explicit formulation of rules, common law is thought to emerge from a complex doctrine of precedential constraint, according to which decisions in earlier cases constrain later courts while still allowing these courts the freedom to address new situations in creative ways. Although this doctrine is applied by legal practitioners on a daily basis, it has proved to be considerably more difficult to develop an adequate theoretical account of the doctrine itself. Drawing on recent work in legal theory, as well as AI and law, this book develops a new account of precedential constraint and the balance achieved in the common law between constraint and freedom. This account, which involves construction of a group priority ordering among reasons, is then applied to other topics including the semantics of open-textured predicates and the practice of making exceptions to general rules.
Industry Reviews
'This book is both clever and insightful, with several powerful and illuminating results and advances both conceptual and technical. It's deeply informed by a leading understanding of existing work in legal theory as well as in logic and artificial intelligence - a really impressive intellectual and scholarly accomplishment as well as an achievement in logic and philosophy. It should be required reading for anyone with an interest in legal reasoning or jurisprudence.' Mark Schroeder, University of Southern California

More in Philosophy

Wabi Sabi : Japanese Wisdom for a Perfectly Imperfect Life - Beth Kempton
Man's Search For Meaning - Viktor E Frankl

RRP $16.99

$15.80

The Choice : A true story of hope - Edith Eger

RRP $24.99

$21.75

13%
OFF
The Prophet : Penguin Classics Hardcover - Kahlil Gibran

RRP $32.99

$26.95

18%
OFF
Humankind : A Hopeful History - Rutger Bregman

RRP $24.99

$21.75

13%
OFF
The Creative Act : A Way of Being - Rick Rubin

RRP $49.99

$38.75

22%
OFF
We Who Wrestle With God : Perceptions of the Divine - Jordan B. Peterson
Ikigai : The Japanese Secret to a Long and Happy Life - Hector Garcia
The Boy, The Mole, The Fox and The Horse - Charlie Mackesy

RRP $40.00

$24.00

40%
OFF
12 Rules for Life : Antidote to Chaos - Jordan B. Peterson

RRP $22.99

$18.90

18%
OFF
Bright Shining : how grace changes everything - Julia Baird

RRP $34.99

$28.50

19%
OFF
Nuked : The Submarine Fiasco that Sank Australia's Sovereignty - Andrew Fowler
The Heart of Yoga : Developing a Personal Practice - T. K. V. Desikachar